Click here to return to the Web version
A shipwrecked sailor is stranded on a small desert island with no fresh water to drink. She knows she could last without food for up to a month, but if she didn't have water to drink she would be dead within a week. Hoping to postpone the inevitable, her thirst drove her to drink the salty seawater. She was dead in two days. Why do you think drinking seawater killed the sailor faster than not drinking any water at all? Today we explore the cause of the sailor's death. We'll prepare solutions of salt water to represent the sea, and we'll cut up slices of potato to represent the sailor. Potatoes are made of cells, as is the sailor!
To determine the cause of the sailor's death, we will determine the effects of salt water on slices of potato. Our assumption is that potato cells will behave like the sailor's cells in her body. We will compare salt water to fresh water so we can see if there is an effect caused by the salt in the water. The fresh water acts as a control in this experiment.
|
|
Square off the ends of the potato so that it is at least 8 cm long. Stand it on end and bore three vertical holes. Space them close together so that one or two other groups can use the rest of the potato. Remeasure the cylinders you remove from the cork borer and, if necessary, recut them so that they are all exactly the same length. Record the actual length in the table. |
|
Desired final concentration |
amount of dilution |
|
50 ml total volume
= |
amount of stock |
|
50 ml total - amount of stock = |
amount of water |
Percent Sea Water |
Vol. of 20% Salt Water (ml) |
Vol. of Fresh Water (ml) |
Total Vol. (ml) |
10% Sea Water |
100.0 |
||
5% Sea Water |
100.0 |
||
1% Sea Water |
100.0 |
||
Fresh Water |
0.0 |
100.0 |
100.0 |
Place a slice of potato into each of the four cups. Cover the cups with saran wrap using a rubber band to hold the wrap securely in place. Why is it important to cover the cups overnight?
Measure the length of the potato slices being careful to make a note of which slice belongs to which cup! Enter the change in size into the data table. Use a plus (+) to indicate a slice has grown and a minus (–) to indicate a slice has shrunk overnight. (Example +2 mm means grew 2 mm / –3 mm means shrunk 3 mm).
Sample |
Initial Length (Day 1) |
Final Length (Day 2) |
Change in Length |
Turgidity |
Tonicity |
|||
¾ ¾ ¾ |
¾ ¾ ¾ |
¾ ¾ ¾ |
Crisp |
Flaccid |
Hypo- |
Iso- |
Hyper- |
|
10 % Salt |
cm. |
|||||||
5% Salt |
cm. |
|||||||
1% Salt |
cm. |
|||||||
Fresh Water |
cm. |
|||||||
Your instructor will give instructions on how to do this. What are the variables we are testing in this laboratory? What data are we collecting?
Write a formal report of this lab using the usual format. In the discussion, you MUST address the following questions.
What happened overnight to the potato slices? Why did it happen?
Is diffusion or osmosis responsible for changes in length of the potato slices? Define both these terms.
Which of the three solutions is isotonic to potato cells? How do you know this?
Define hypertonic, isotonic, and hypotonic.
Why did the sailor die more quickly drinking salt water than not drinking at all? What do you think killed the sailor?